I worked with one of my fellow beer drinkers to run a scotch tasting for my Home Brew club (the Lincoln Lagers) a few weeks ago. I made a single sheet, two column, tasting sheet with a brief primer on scotch and regions in one column and blank lines for notes in the other.
We started off by sampling an average blended scotch (Grant's). We then moved on to sample a scotch from each of the 4 major regions:
Auchentoshan for Lowland
Glenmorangie for Highland
Glen Moray 12 for Speyside, and
Bowmore Darkest as our Islay
Needless to say, just about everybody who showed up brought their own bottles as well, resulting in, well. . . you can see here:
We even had a Cicerone in attendance who let us borrow a hundred of his 4oz brandy snifters for the tasting, fresh glasses for each scotch!
Needless to say, we all had a grand time and perhaps had too much to drink. . . We're looking to try it again, but next time we'll concentrate on a single region.
Incidentally, for those of you interested, I donated the Bowmore (an $80 bottle), but the other 4 were obtained for under a $140. We charged about 10 bucks ahead, and to compensate for the door, my partner got to keep the leftover scotch for footing the bill. All told, we were only out about 30 bucks, even with appetizers, etc. And quite frankly, entertaining a dozen friends and drinking some great scotch was a great fun/cost ratio.