The ( real ) TGR A/S product
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
The ( real ) TGR A/S product
Ahem.....moving right along...the actual TGR aftershave poultice...yes, interesting stuff. This new product has, of course, been highly touted recently on shaveblog.com, as well as having found favor with a few avante garde members, like Reg and Stan. So, this morning I gave it a try. I was especially interested because this stuff has been put forth as a candidate to substitute for the disappearing older version of Harris's Aftershave Milk, a product that I love, that is/was rather unique, and that I helped popularize on the shave forums.
Well, I knew this TGR product HAD to be at least a little different, due to the ingrediants in it, and, sure enough...the texture is less liquid then the Milk. More the consistancy of a light weight balm or gel. That is to say, that it didn't pour, exactly, but stayed somewhat clumped together ( the sample I have is in a small pump dispenser ). BUT, upon application, it did indeed seem much like the Harris's product. A light scent that passed quickly, very quick absorbtion, and, wonderfully, no hint of slickness, oilyness, or being "moisturized" afterwards. It did it's soothing work, and disappeared. And, my finicky skin had no negative reaction to it, neither upon application, nor later on. Hallelujah! They got it 'right'. So, is this what I'm now going to use when the old Milk runs out? Well, probably not, but only because the Harris's Pink also works very well for me. But, if that didn't exist, then, yeah, I probably would, despite the hefty price tag, and the fact that it does seem just a teensy weensy bit heavier weight. Afterall, I tell myself, I used to use the AOS Aftershave Gel, and that was darn near as pricey as the TGR stuff. In overall feel and effect, this TGR product is, indeed, the closest thing I've tried to the old D R Harris's A/S Milk.
Regards,
Gordon
Well, I knew this TGR product HAD to be at least a little different, due to the ingrediants in it, and, sure enough...the texture is less liquid then the Milk. More the consistancy of a light weight balm or gel. That is to say, that it didn't pour, exactly, but stayed somewhat clumped together ( the sample I have is in a small pump dispenser ). BUT, upon application, it did indeed seem much like the Harris's product. A light scent that passed quickly, very quick absorbtion, and, wonderfully, no hint of slickness, oilyness, or being "moisturized" afterwards. It did it's soothing work, and disappeared. And, my finicky skin had no negative reaction to it, neither upon application, nor later on. Hallelujah! They got it 'right'. So, is this what I'm now going to use when the old Milk runs out? Well, probably not, but only because the Harris's Pink also works very well for me. But, if that didn't exist, then, yeah, I probably would, despite the hefty price tag, and the fact that it does seem just a teensy weensy bit heavier weight. Afterall, I tell myself, I used to use the AOS Aftershave Gel, and that was darn near as pricey as the TGR stuff. In overall feel and effect, this TGR product is, indeed, the closest thing I've tried to the old D R Harris's A/S Milk.
Regards,
Gordon
Well, color me interested. It'll be a while before I run through my stash of old Harris a/s milk, but once I do (and let's face it, probably before that) I'll give the TGR balm a try. It sounds like good stuff.
Now I have to admit to some curiosity, Gordon, as the identity of the stuff you were using yesterday that was NOT the TGR balm. I can certainly understand that if you were expecting a Harris milk-like concoction, and got a heavy balm, that you'd be down on the stuff. Thinking back, though (and putting yourself in a Northern winter), do you think that mystery product was worthwhile? Just curious.
Now I have to admit to some curiosity, Gordon, as the identity of the stuff you were using yesterday that was NOT the TGR balm. I can certainly understand that if you were expecting a Harris milk-like concoction, and got a heavy balm, that you'd be down on the stuff. Thinking back, though (and putting yourself in a Northern winter), do you think that mystery product was worthwhile? Just curious.
--Bob--
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
- rustyblade
- Shaving Paparazzo
- Posts: 10472
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 5:27 pm
- Location: Ontario
Very interesting Gordon. Sounds like decent stuff and it is supposedly made of quality ingredients. Many aftershaves (Proraso balm for example) seem to contain a chemical soup of ingredients. I too was wondering about that balm switcheroo incident but was too polite to dig any deeper into it.....
Richard
- reggiano
- Posts: 2225
- Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2006 8:20 pm
- Location: Greater NYC Metropolitan Regional Area
Gordon-
Great review. Sounds like we are on the same page.
True story. I have sensitive skin, and have been treated by dermatologists, and prescriped various creams and ointments for my face. Used to use Elecon, now use a non-steroid ointment, Protopic, which is great. For a short time my doc prescribed Eledel. One day I was having a bad reaction, skin red and blotchy, itchy etc. I had no medication so called my doc, who told me he would call in Eledel to my pharmacy. I pick up the prescription, and sat in my car in the parking lot and smeared the cream all over my face, thinking that it seemed a bit different than how I remembered. Oh, and the packaging looked diffferent too. Oh, and what is it called? Aldara? That doesn't seem right.
Go home and call my doc." Aldara? I didn't prescribe that. Aldara is for genital warts! Relax, you'll be OK. Take a shower immediately."
Anyway, no moral to the story except that you probably shouldn't put genital wart cream on your face. Oh, and TGR ASB gets a nod from Gordon.
Great review. Sounds like we are on the same page.
True story. I have sensitive skin, and have been treated by dermatologists, and prescriped various creams and ointments for my face. Used to use Elecon, now use a non-steroid ointment, Protopic, which is great. For a short time my doc prescribed Eledel. One day I was having a bad reaction, skin red and blotchy, itchy etc. I had no medication so called my doc, who told me he would call in Eledel to my pharmacy. I pick up the prescription, and sat in my car in the parking lot and smeared the cream all over my face, thinking that it seemed a bit different than how I remembered. Oh, and the packaging looked diffferent too. Oh, and what is it called? Aldara? That doesn't seem right.
Go home and call my doc." Aldara? I didn't prescribe that. Aldara is for genital warts! Relax, you'll be OK. Take a shower immediately."
Anyway, no moral to the story except that you probably shouldn't put genital wart cream on your face. Oh, and TGR ASB gets a nod from Gordon.
What a story! Hopefully your pharmacist isn't someone who you were wanting to ask out on a date.reggiano wrote:Gordon-
Great review. Sounds like we are on the same page.
True story. I have sensitive skin, and have been treated by dermatologists, and prescriped various creams and ointments for my face. Used to use Elecon, now use a non-steroid ointment, Protopic, which is great. For a short time my doc prescribed Eledel. One day I was having a bad reaction, skin red and blotchy, itchy etc. I had no medication so called my doc, who told me he would call in Eledel to my pharmacy. I pick up the prescription, and sat in my car in the parking lot and smeared the cream all over my face, thinking that it seemed a bit different than how I remembered. Oh, and the packaging looked diffferent too. Oh, and what is it called? Aldara? That doesn't seem right.
Go home and call my doc." Aldara? I didn't prescribe that. Aldara is for genital warts! Relax, you'll be OK. Take a shower immediately."
Anyway, no moral to the story except that you probably shouldn't put genital wart cream on your face. Oh, and TGR ASB gets a nod from Gordon.
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
-
- Mad Max
- Posts: 408
- Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2005 3:38 pm
- Location: Vermont
- reggiano
- Posts: 2225
- Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2006 8:20 pm
- Location: Greater NYC Metropolitan Regional Area
A little definitely goes a long way. Unfortunately this is becoming a daily habit for me, whereas in the past I rotated my balms, so I'll see how long this lasts.northadams wrote:I guess the sticking point now for some is that high price tag. In his shaveblog review Corey did think he might be able to get a years worth of use from the product which is sounds promising.
Max
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
-
- Mad Max
- Posts: 408
- Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2005 3:38 pm
- Location: Vermont
Well, you have to give a nod to that clip & ship USPS service. The TGR A/S arrived in less than 48 hrs from Las Vegas to Vermont and with the free shipping you can't beat that. Having used the product twice now I can see it definitely replacing what leftover (old version) Harris milk I still have. I have been using the Harris and the CAR a/s but the latter just became too heavy for me. The TGR a/s appears milky and maybe slightly heavier than the Harris version but not really anything too noticeable at all. It sinks in quick, does its job as a light a/s should but what I like about it is it seems even less greasy than the (old) Harris milk was if that's possible. Nothing like a coral skin food at all but it also appears to have a sealant post shave feel (against those elements) more than the Harris milk did. After two applications I don't see a bottle lasting a year but well... that free shipping. I also don't see TGR a/s being buried in my grave like Mr. Greenberg will certainly do (after a long & healthy life don't forget) but his review, at least to me, was right on the money.
Max
Max
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
Afternoon, Well, I still stand by what I posted above, but I must admit that after a couple of days, I started to have what appeared to be some sort of minor skin reaction to the TGR A/S. I'll need to double check, and in any case, it is somewhat irrelevant in the context of other members, as skin reactions of this sort are of a very personal nature. The product does work in the manner that I, Max, and others have described, and probably should be #1 on the list of things to try when one's old formula A/S Milk runs out. Myself, on that dark day, I will return to using Harris's Pink.
Regards,
Gordon
Regards,
Gordon
From Perry at TGR:
"...According to re orders from clients a 100ml ASB bottle is lasting 4 to 10 weeks. My balm lasts me around 5 weeks shaving 5 times per week. "
I was hoping a bottle would last at least 3-4 months for the hefty price tag, but it is good stuff. Maybe I'll cut down on the number of pumps I'm using per shave, I'm doing 3 now and maybe it's too much.
"...According to re orders from clients a 100ml ASB bottle is lasting 4 to 10 weeks. My balm lasts me around 5 weeks shaving 5 times per week. "
I was hoping a bottle would last at least 3-4 months for the hefty price tag, but it is good stuff. Maybe I'll cut down on the number of pumps I'm using per shave, I'm doing 3 now and maybe it's too much.
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
Chris, Well, that's interesting. A 100ml bottle of the old Harris's Milk always lasts me exactly four months. But I would have thought that the TGR product might last a little longer, as it's a bit heavier weight, and presumably one could use a little less per shave. BTW, I shave daily, seven days a week.
Regards,
Gordon
Regards,
Gordon
- rustyblade
- Shaving Paparazzo
- Posts: 10472
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 5:27 pm
- Location: Ontario
I would reckon it should last longer than that. For me (which doesn't count because I rotate A/S in some sort of non-order) I use about 1/3 of a pump which should last many months with daily use. A full pump's worth would be too much. It is quite heavy feeling (yet is surprisingly soothing and doesn't leave the skin tacky at all). I apply a bit of witch hazel spray to my face first and then apply the balm so it goes further. Good stuff, but I wouldn't pay the price for it again. It is shockingly expensive to get some up here despite the fact it originates from the Great White North (and probably down the street from our business to add insult to injury).
Richard
-
- Mad Max
- Posts: 408
- Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2005 3:38 pm
- Location: Vermont