Floid Blue vs Proraso New Formula

[Rufus]

I'm looking to expand my collection of aftershaves and want to add a good quality menthol aftershave. The only aftershave containing menthol I have is Royal Bay Rhum, which I enjoy greatly. I am considering Floid Blue and Proraso New Formula, but don't want to buy both if they have similar scents. Your advice please.

[beartrap]

They do not have similar scents, to my nose anyway. Blue has more powdery scent and little less menthol kick.