Page 1 of 5

Simpsons Gary Young Limited Edition M7

Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 1:46 pm
by drP
I thought that this limited edition Simpson deserved more attention hence this thread.
I acquired both versions and had no intention to use them but today i couldn't withstand its sirene call. So today was its maidentrip.
The brush itself is well constructed as might be expected from the Vulfix company. The loft is fairly dense but this kind of silvertip badger reminds me more of the best badger in the bigger Somersets from the Carter era in my collection. It has a yellow/light brown shade over it compared to other three band Simpsons supers.
The handle has a very attractive shape and turned out to be superbly ergonomical during use. It's in fact the most ergonomical handle of all brushes in my collection together with the handles of the PL8 and Colonel. Kudo's for Vulfix to revive this handle shape. The signature of Gary on the back of the brush adds to the LE status of the brush.
The material used could have been more marbled but that's a pure personal matter and has nothing to do with quality.
Being a Simpsons purist/traditionalist i applied the water soluble Carter decals. Looks much nicer than the imprinting imho. The current decals aren't suitable since the edge of the decal doesn't look nice and clean on the material of the handle.
It was clear that the brush definitely has to be broken in yet. It lost a few bristles though nothing to worry about.
There's enough backbone and the tips are pleasantly soft. The loft doesn't bloom much after use.

I'd rather had this M7 to be made with two band super like the LE Astor brush is. And preferrably with an ivory coloured handle too...sigh...
But alas, you can't allways get what you want... :wink:

There are lots of pics in the shopping section. Here two more pics: one with the lather just made and one after rinsing the loft.

Image

Image

Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 2:24 pm
by IsaacRN
Sadly, I am still waiting for my brush. I have to ask you, do you notice any difference in what was described as extremely super badger hair?

Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 2:24 pm
by CMur12
That looks good, Peter. Thanks for all the photos.

I, personally, have always appreciated a brush with controlled bloom.

- Murray

Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 6:18 pm
by drumana
It's a beautiful brush, for sure. Love the handle design.

Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 7:20 pm
by Nitrox
Yes, the handle is very nice indeed. The bristle looks like the old best badger that Simpson used in their brushes before Vulfix took over.

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 3:14 am
by Whistler
The bristles feel just like my Somerset PL8 Best, a bit of scritch to it.

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 4:39 am
by fallingwickets
Use in good health, Peter

clive

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 6:46 am
by Thalay Sagar
Whistler wrote:The bristles feel just like my Somerset PL8 Best, a bit of scritch to it.
A beautiful brush, but now I am relieved that I did not buy one.

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 8:39 am
by SRD
Enjoy it Peter. Thanks for your review.

Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 12:11 pm
by churchilllafemme
A very nice looking brush, Peter. Maybe some years in the future, when it has become not just a LE but also a classic, you'll be willing to sell it to me.

Posted: Tue Aug 23, 2011 7:33 am
by kbuzbee
Peter, I'm glad you were overwhelmed enough to give this guy a go! Well done, Sir!

Like you, I'd rather it had been a super stiff two band.... Regardless...

Cheers,

Ken

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 4:19 am
by river1
Peter, thanks for a very objective review of the brush. The comparison to the Sommersets and following comments were also interesting. After seeing one of your Simpson displays, a brush review by you takes on new importance to me. Doug

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 8:57 am
by stanmog
It is a nice brush, but for the same price one can have two real horn handled blond badger Morris and Forndran brushes. The M7 handle is very ergonomic, an ideal size and weight. The badger bristle reminds me of the Rooney emillion, but not as densely packed. But the M7 pales in comparison to the M+F in function (lathering), face feel, and value for price.

Regards,
Stan

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 10:23 am
by Gary Young
stanmog wrote:It is a nice brush, but for the same price one can have two real horn handled blond badger Morris and Forndran brushes. The M7 handle is very ergonomic, an ideal size and weight. The badger bristle reminds me of the Rooney emillion, but not as densely packed. But the M7 pales in comparison to the M+F in function (lathering), face feel, and value for price.

Regards,
Stan
Stan

This brush was never pitched against M & F brushes when myself and Mark looked at this collaboration. Two different sides of the playing field.

Gary

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 11:30 am
by ltjaw
stanmog wrote:It is a nice brush, but for the same price one can have two real horn handled blond badger Morris and Forndran brushes. The M7 handle is very ergonomic, an ideal size and weight. The badger bristle reminds me of the Rooney emillion, but not as densely packed. But the M7 pales in comparison to the M+F in function (lathering), face feel, and value for price.

Regards,
Stan
Can't the same be said of any brush costing more than $200-$250? I think one is paying for more than quality and performance here. Exclusivity. Uniqueness. Whatever it is, there are those willing to pay extra, and I am occasionally such a person.

That being said, I have not purchased one. I would love to see this become a standard offering in the regular white handle, offered in 2 and 3 band Super.

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 12:49 pm
by Fido
stanmog wrote:It is a nice brush, but for the same price one can have two real horn handled blond badger Morris and Forndran brushes. The M7 handle is very ergonomic, an ideal size and weight. The badger bristle reminds me of the Rooney emillion, but not as densely packed. But the M7 pales in comparison to the M+F in function (lathering), face feel, and value for price.

Regards,
Stan
Stan, is this opinion based on having used one of these M7 brushes?

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 12:49 pm
by stanmog
yes

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 12:50 pm
by Fido
That was quick, thanks!

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 1:22 pm
by Sam
I do like the look of this handle. I think it would be neat to have Simpson/Vulfix do limited editions. Say to celebrate something, do a handle like this, use Best hair, and make the handle in say the colors of the British Flag. I think bringing in a brush around $150 would go over great, take preorders of say up to 300, or 500, or whatever number justifies the run.

A mottled look Peter, yes, I quite agree. The brush appears black on my monitor, and maybe it is not a wood handle. The first SMF brush was unique in that cocobola was so different from the handles in the past before we had all sorts of artisinal vendors cropping up. Some of the other matierials, like the stone ones, well, not as tactile to me, but this handle looks like one of those older bakelite models we see on ebay from time to time

Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2011 2:15 pm
by drP
Sam,

Here's a better picture to get an impression of the handle material.

Image