Derby Blades, A Review
Derby Blades, A Review
For your reviewing pleasure, the Derby blades.
Description: Made in Turkey using a formula of Chromium/Ceramic/Platinum-Tungsten and Polymer coated edges this blade has often been referred to on our Board and here's why:
Charistics: Presented in a standard plastic box of five the green label does not imply where these blades originate, rather UK looking actually, the blades are single wrapped and are very clean with a disposable slot in the box.
I included two photos of the edge which is quite interesting. The edge is a two hone, the first from the blade table being long and very even, the second being very short, good quality control here, this is the largest photo my equipment can do but I examined the entire length of the blade and both hone lines are very consistent, referring back to my earlier blade review edge photos this edge is visibly a higher quality.
Use: In four out of five razors this blade shaved me very well. An easy, effortlessly gliding shave like a ball of mercury rolling across a pane of smooth glass. Beautiful performance, the day after my test concluded I called Giovanni and ordered another 500. Just hedging my bet against them selling the factory or something.
Conclusion: I can recommend this blade highly, it will not work in every razor every time, it didn't work that well in one of my proven razors, but it is so consistently good I understand why it's so popular. Rated 7.
Post edited on 10-29-11. The blades reviewed here were manufactured at least six years ago and may not reflect the current quality manufacture of this brand.
Description: Made in Turkey using a formula of Chromium/Ceramic/Platinum-Tungsten and Polymer coated edges this blade has often been referred to on our Board and here's why:
Charistics: Presented in a standard plastic box of five the green label does not imply where these blades originate, rather UK looking actually, the blades are single wrapped and are very clean with a disposable slot in the box.
I included two photos of the edge which is quite interesting. The edge is a two hone, the first from the blade table being long and very even, the second being very short, good quality control here, this is the largest photo my equipment can do but I examined the entire length of the blade and both hone lines are very consistent, referring back to my earlier blade review edge photos this edge is visibly a higher quality.
Use: In four out of five razors this blade shaved me very well. An easy, effortlessly gliding shave like a ball of mercury rolling across a pane of smooth glass. Beautiful performance, the day after my test concluded I called Giovanni and ordered another 500. Just hedging my bet against them selling the factory or something.
Conclusion: I can recommend this blade highly, it will not work in every razor every time, it didn't work that well in one of my proven razors, but it is so consistently good I understand why it's so popular. Rated 7.
Post edited on 10-29-11. The blades reviewed here were manufactured at least six years ago and may not reflect the current quality manufacture of this brand.
Last edited by Squire on Sat Oct 29, 2011 7:48 am, edited 1 time in total.
Regards,
Squire
Squire
- D.Irving79
- The Great Lord Protector of the SE!
- Posts: 3311
- Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2008 1:03 pm
- Location: CRANFORD, NJ
-
- Posts: 368
- Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2008 5:58 pm
-
- Duke of Silvertip!
- Posts: 27393
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 1:02 pm
Squire, A most informative review. I'm usually not a nut for microscopic photos of blade edges, but I found these interesting. I've used Derbys only a few times, and wasn't overly fond of them, but I probably should revisit them at some point. Perhaps I got a couple of bummers, or maybe the razor I was using was not suitable for them. Thanks again for the time and effort.
Regards,
Gordon
Regards,
Gordon
-
- Posts: 246
- Joined: Tue Apr 12, 2005 1:43 pm
Re: Derby Blades, A Review
Squire, this is a very impressive review, well done.Squire wrote: Beautiful performance, the day after my test concluded I called Giovanni and ordered another 500. Just hedging my bet against them selling the factory or something.
I love the Derbys and must have at least 800 of them lying around. I bought 200 once and then they had a deal a while back where you buy about 400 and get 200 free or something like that.
They also threw in all 4 creams, which I wasn't too fond of though.
They work well in all my razors, including the aggressive Merkur razors.
Bruno
"Shhhhhaving cream, be nice and clean
shave every day and you'll always look keen."
"Shhhhhaving cream, be nice and clean
shave every day and you'll always look keen."
- TorzJohnson
- Posts: 554
- Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2007 6:49 pm
- Location: NY
George, if you look on one end of the box, there is a little flap / trap door that you can open to take out blades. At the other end is a small slot. I just put the old blades in that slot.george wrote:Okay, I have a question... I cannot find the used blade slot on the Derby boxes. I can find it quite easily on the Merkur box and the Gillette box, but the Derby seems to be all closed up.
Am I blind? Ignorant? I may sound dense, but I'll play my Noob card as a defense...
Jim
-
- Posts: 2347
- Joined: Wed Mar 07, 2007 10:38 am
- Location: Fresno, CA
I agree that the razor plays a part in how a blade works or feels. In my Merkur HD, a Derby feels harsh. In a Super Speed, it feels smooth and sharp, something I would buy again. Interestingly, in my Merkur Travel Razor (3-part razor, not counting the screw-apart handle), the Derby feels better than in my HD (two-part razor). The Travel Razor, aside from the head, is also a much lighter razor, so the balance and feel may affect the way I shave and how the blade feels.
Dave
"Sanity is a madness put to good use." - George Santayana (…like a wet shaver with an acquisition disorder.)
"Sanity is a madness put to good use." - George Santayana (…like a wet shaver with an acquisition disorder.)
- mantic
- Wielder of the Zorrick
- Posts: 2390
- Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2004 11:47 pm
- Location: Somewhere Between Snook and North Zulch, TX
If you have a broadband connection this video should help as well (about 1:20 into the video; it shows a Feather magazine but Derby is the same).TorzJohnson wrote:George, if you look on one end of the box, there is a little flap / trap door that you can open to take out blades. At the other end is a small slot. I just put the old blades in that slot.george wrote:Okay, I have a question... I cannot find the used blade slot on the Derby boxes. I can find it quite easily on the Merkur box and the Gillette box, but the Derby seems to be all closed up.
Am I blind? Ignorant? I may sound dense, but I'll play my Noob card as a defense...
--Mark
I'll recheck, but the Feather magazine in the video looked just like the Merkur I have: new blades out the top on one side, old blades in the bottom on the opposite.mantic wrote:If you have a broadband connection this video should help as well (about 1:20 into the video; it shows a Feather magazine but Derby is the same).TorzJohnson wrote:George, if you look on one end of the box, there is a little flap / trap door that you can open to take out blades. At the other end is a small slot. I just put the old blades in that slot.george wrote:Okay, I have a question... I cannot find the used blade slot on the Derby boxes. I can find it quite easily on the Merkur box and the Gillette box, but the Derby seems to be all closed up.
Am I blind? Ignorant? I may sound dense, but I'll play my Noob card as a defense...
--Mark
But the Derby mag doesn't seem to have that opening for the old blades. I'll have to check again.
So far, though, I'm not a big fan of the Derbys in my 38C. I've ordered a Weishi and I'll try them in there and see how that works.
Thanks!
-
- Posts: 935
- Joined: Fri Feb 23, 2007 2:07 pm
- Location: USA
Like so many gents around here, I love the Derby blades.
This past week I decided to try Gillette Platinums again, thinking that maybe I'd been unfair in my prior evaluation of it. So I switched from Derby blade to a Gillette blade.
My first Gillette shave was just terrific. Close, comfortable, no irritation, and still smooth at dinner time.
After the second day, however, my face got really irritated (as it has in the past with the Gillette Platinums).
So . . . . back to the Derbys! After just a couple of "repair" shaves, I'm back to my normal close, super-comfortable Derby shave.
For me, Derby hits the "sweet spot" where it's sharp enough to cut, and yet gentle enough not to cause any injury.
This past week I decided to try Gillette Platinums again, thinking that maybe I'd been unfair in my prior evaluation of it. So I switched from Derby blade to a Gillette blade.
My first Gillette shave was just terrific. Close, comfortable, no irritation, and still smooth at dinner time.
After the second day, however, my face got really irritated (as it has in the past with the Gillette Platinums).
So . . . . back to the Derbys! After just a couple of "repair" shaves, I'm back to my normal close, super-comfortable Derby shave.
For me, Derby hits the "sweet spot" where it's sharp enough to cut, and yet gentle enough not to cause any injury.
-
- Posts: 935
- Joined: Fri Feb 23, 2007 2:07 pm
- Location: USA
Yes. Vision set on mild. I agree that switching razors would have introduced a variable that would invalidate the comparison. So, whilst keeping the razor as a constant, the comparison was the Gillette blade vs. the Derby blade (in the Vision razor).Good BF, were you using the same razor?
For me, although I admire the sharpness of the Gillette, it's just too rough on my skin. I do better (in fact, so far I do best) with a Derby.
If I had tougher skin, it might be a different comparison. But we have to play the hand (or face) we are dealt!
It is always amazing how these discussions evolve.
First a very "scientific" view of the blade edge. And it slowly eroded away to where the used blade slot is on the blade container.
Anyway.......I have heard, from what I consider to be a reliable source that there isn't any platinum in/on razor blades, as many of them claim to have. Years ago my employer investigated "recycling" razor blades for the sake of reclaiming the supposed platinum.
First a very "scientific" view of the blade edge. And it slowly eroded away to where the used blade slot is on the blade container.
Anyway.......I have heard, from what I consider to be a reliable source that there isn't any platinum in/on razor blades, as many of them claim to have. Years ago my employer investigated "recycling" razor blades for the sake of reclaiming the supposed platinum.
"You have rights antecedent to all earthly governments; rights that cannot be repealed or restrained by human laws; rights derived from the Great Legislator of the Universe." -John Adams, Second President of the United States